Getting Insurance M&A Right
19 November, 2026
Seven themes for building lasting value through M&A
A study by Oxbow Partners and Insurtech NY
M&A can help insurers enter new markets, build capabilities and accelerate growth, but many deals fall short of their potential.
Our new report, ‘Getting Insurance M&A Right: Seven themes for building lasting value through M&A‘ combines analysis of M&A activity at publicly traded insurers with interviews across buyers, sellers and advisers to understand why. It identifies seven recurring challenges across the M&A lifecycle and what successful acquirers do differently.
- Building a clear business case and strategic rationale
- Getting diligence right
- Designing integration early
- Getting culture and talent right
- Engaging stakeholders effectively
- Building integration leadership and capacity
- Maintaining post-deal focus and tracking value
One finding stands out: practice matters. The most active acquirers outperformed occasional acquirers, highlighting the importance of building M&A capability before an opportunity arises.
This report explores what goes wrong, what good looks like and how insurers can improve their readiness for future deals.
🎧 Prefer to listen? Listen to a short summary of the report’s key findings:
Listen to the executive summary
About the authors
Manmeet Singh Bawa, Partner, New York – Oxbow Partners. Manmeet leading Oxbow Partners’ US business from New York. He brings over a decade of global consulting experience, advising leading insurers and multinational organisations on strategy, innovation, and business model transformation. Manmeet has deep expertise across the P&C insurance sector, supporting clients on growth strategy, business model innovation, operating model transformation, embedded insurance, ecosystem partnerships, and data-driven performance improvement. A recognised thought leader in the industry, Manmeet has published extensively on insurance innovation and is a regular speaker at industry events.
Paul De’Ath, Head of Market Intelligence – Oxbow Partners. Paul leads Oxbow Partners’ Market Intelligence team, helping insurers, investors and other industry participants understand how the market is changing and what those changes mean for their businesses. He has extensive experience analysing the UK and European insurance markets, including nine years as an equity research analyst covering the sector. Paul oversees all of Oxbow Partners’ external thought leadership, setting the agenda for the firm’s market-facing research and content. He authors several major pieces of research each year, providing perspectives on the structural, competitive and financial trends shaping the insurance industry.
David Gritz, Co-founder & Managing Director – Insurtech NY. David Gritz is a venture capitalist, InsurTech community leader, and InsurTech advisor. David serves as the Managing Director of InsurTech Fund and InsurTech NY. InsurTech NY is the largest InsurTech community in North America. It helps insurers connect to high-potential startups through a Global InsurTech Competition, a growth-stage accelerator, and an MGA Lab. Previously, David served as the Director of Innovation for the Silicon Valley Insurance Accelerator (SVIA) and co-founded Zero, a behavioral safety-focused InsurTech acquired by EverestRe.